KHV = Herpesvirus?

Recent studies in Israel may indicate that the virus that was the cause of mass mortalities in Koi and carp populations worldwide, may not be a Herpesvirus after all. It is now thought to be a large DNA viral particle under an electron microscope that mimics the Herpesvirus.

Since May 1998 several outbreaks of what has become known as Koi Herpesvirus(KHV) caused mass mortalities in private stocks and fish farms in the northwest of Israel, the mid-Atlantic region of the USA, and in different locations elsewhere in the world, resulting in enormous financial losses for those enterprises concerned. The most recent outbreak in mid-April in East Java, Indonesia caused losses estimated at US$5 million. It will have a negative effect to the region's koi export industry no doubt.

In the May 2002 issue of OFI Journal, John Dawes provides an update on the status of the Koi viral disease in Israel and illuminates it with some of the latest research findings. The message is certainly that there is life after KHV, but more important, the virus may not be a Herpesvirus after all. This bodes well for the industry since the disease may not exhibit the fatal long term characteristics expected of a Herpesvirus.

To summarize the gist of the article: (sometimes verbatim, without permission) The initial 1998 Israeli outbreak was followed by three others within 18 months; each on a different farm. Each of these outbreaks has been contained and overcome within a period of 12-18 months and the output of clean fish generally became possible 12-18 months after completion of the eradication programs. The virus linked with the disease has been accepted as being a Herpesvirus (Hedrick et al, 2000) especially because transmission electron micrographs showed the viral particles exhibit the characteristic Herpesvirus shape when viewed in cross section at high magnitude. However, recent research by Professor Moshe Kotler and colleagues at The Hebrew University and the team led by Dr. Izhak Bejerano at the Israeli Central Fish Health Laboratory, indicates that the virus may be a double-stranded DNA virus with icosahedron morphology that makes it resemble a Herpesvirus. (An icosahedron is a solid body with twenty plane faces, only a few of which can be seen in cross sectional view under transmission electron microscopic examination). This may help explain the results of the various tests, experiments and field trials that have been carried out over the past few years. It may also mean that the periods of latency (dormancy) that are characteristic of Herpesviruses - such as those that cause cold sores in humans - may not apply to the Koi virus. This has significant implications for the rapid restoration of an infected Koi farm to good health. Logically, if the causative agent is not a Herpesvirus, the disease will require renaming, since the KHV label will no longer apply.

The researchers carried out numerous tests on what they termed NIF's (natural immune fish). The main conclusions derived from these tests are that:

  1. NIF's do not infect fish which have never been exposed to the virus before, irrespective of whether these are newly-hatched fry, or fish at any other stage of maturity; and
  2. NIF's do not appear to be carriers; and
  3. NIF's do not appear to carry antibodies against the disease; and
  4. NIF's do not appear to harbour any viral particles.

The results so far obtained do not constitute scientific proof and more research is needed, but their immunisation procedure by which NIF's are produced by exposure to sick fish, is showing positive results, which in turn supports the above.

Let us not be overly hasty in dropping the name KHV. Allow science to do its job and come up with a suggestion.


Special Updates
SVC in the USA

Below the latest information from the OIE website concerning the SVC outbreak in the the US:


Spring Viraemia Of Carp In The United States Of America

(Disease never reported before).
Emergency report

Information received from Dr Peter Fernandez, Associate Deputy Administrator, International Services, United States

Department of Agriculture (USDA), Washington, DC:
Report date: 11 July 2002.
Nature of diagnosis: laboratory.
Date of initial detection of animal health incident: 24 April 2002.
Location & No. of outbreaks: Kernersville, State of North Carolina 1 hatchery complex comprising 6 farms
Description of affected population: koi carp (Cyprinus carpio).
Total number of animals in the outbreak*: Susceptible- 150 000, deaths- 15 000, destroyed- 135 000

* The figures refer to the fish population of the two farms that were affected out of a total of six farms in the complex.

Diagnosis:

  1. Laboratories where diagnosis was made:
    • The disease was diagnosed on 24 April 2002 at the University of Arkansas Diagnostic Laboratory at Pine Bluff, State of Arkansas.
    • Diagnosis was confirmed on 5 July 2002 by the Centre for Environment, Fisheries, and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS), Weymouth Laboratory, United Kingdom (OIE Reference Laboratory for spring viraemia of carp).
  2. Diagnostic tests used: tissue culture, immunocytochemistry.
  3. Causal agent: spring viraemia of carp virus (rhabdovirus).

Epidemiology:

  1. Source of agent / origin of infection: the source of infection has not yet been identified.
  2. Other epidemiological details: the possibility of tracing the source of the virus is very limited. The establishment ships and receives fish on a weekly basis.The hatchery is located adjacent to a river and river water is used on the premises.

Control measures

  1. As a result of the detection, 135,000 koi carp were destroyed at the hatchery.
  2. All six farms in the hatchery complex are under quarantine.
  3. The control plan is to depopulate and disinfect the tanks in the holding facility. A disinfection, decontamination, and testing protocol for spring viraemia of carp virus will be used to identify and maintain disease-free ponds and fish.
  4. Fish and Wildlife authorities will be notified because this disease can affect common carp.


Aquarama'03 - A Call For Papers

The next Aquarama Conference will be held in Singapore between 29 May and 1 June 2003. It had issued a call for papers. Billed as the 3rd World Conference on Ornamental Fish Aquaculture, this meeting of leading industry and aquaculture experts is attracting keen interest worldwide. The two previous and highly successful staging of what has already become a highly prestigious event in the aquatic calendar, have combined the latest scientific findings with the hottest - and often most controversial - topics affecting the international ornamental aquatic industry.

For information about your submission contact Julian Lim at julian-lim@cmpasia.com.sg or visit their site at www.aquarama.com.sg for further details.


Editorial Comment

It would seem that the issue of the first appearance of the virus is still not settled. The current epidemic was first witnessed in Israel in May 1998 and is still in full flight migrating across the world. It is insisted by some that the virus was previously detected elsewhere, notably Japan. While there is a large body of evidence pointing to various localised outbreaks of an infectious diseases with high mortality, reports of viral diseases are really much more rare.(really?)

The outbreak in Japan in 1989, reported on by Yoshimizu and Kimura, was identified in follow-up work by Sano, Hedrick and others as Herpesvirus cyprini. Dr RP Hedrick is confident to insist that the 1998 outbreak of KHV was different to the Herpesvirus cyprini. He, Sano and others reported on in the 90's. Still others would like to draw a parallel in the symptoms. Does it matter? Wherever man has cultured things intensively, disease has been a constant threat.

Farmers like to blame others for a disease in their dams. It is nice to say it came from elsewhere while we only have ourselves to blame when things get out of hand. High stocking densities, poor health control and lack of quarantine measures are all essential elements of a disaster in the making. But perhaps we should take it a step further. Once koi farming grows to become a local industry and a national asset, the authorities should step in with regulations to minimise the risk of health hazards and protect farmers from themselves. No one likes regulations, but the damage done to the international koi trade due to bad press and buyer pessimism, is enormous.


Koi Herpesvirus Infection In Indonesia

Suspicion – by Dr Fred Chua, Allpets & Aqualife Clinic

Extract from a report by Dr Akhmad Rukyani, Director, Directorate of Fish Health and Environment, Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries, Jakarta, received on 26 June 2002 from Dr Sofjan Sudarjat, Director General of Livestock Services, Department of Agriculture, Jakarta.

A serious disease outbreak among koi and common carp (Cyprinus Carpio) is currently occurring in Indonesia, having started in the area of Blitar in East Java in mid-April 2002. Since then, it has spread rapidly throughout Java Island, causing very high mortality (80-90%) in both common carp and koi, with an estimated loss of more than 59 billion IDR (approximately US$5 million).

Diagnosis

Clinical signs in infected fish include severe gill necrosis, lots of mucus, superficial haemorrhages, fin rot and enlargement of kidney and liver with haemorrhages and discoloration.

Preliminary investigations conducted by the Fish Health Officers from the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries, suggest a viral infection based on the pattern of outbreak and the clinical signs characteristic of Herpesvirus of Koi. Laboratory examinations are in progress.

Epidemiology

Indonesia has not experienced a disease of this nature in the past. The disease is suspected to have been introduced through importation of koi from another country.

Control Measures

No clear effective measures can be applied to control the disease. The government of Indonesia has officially declared Java Island as an isolated area for the disease. The movement of koi and common carp from Java Island to other islands is strictly prohibited. In addition, importation of koi and common carp into Indonesia is temporarily not permitted.

Back to top

Back


Copyright© 2004-2006 All Rights Reserved